Missing the Point: Livebirth and Stillbirth after IVF
Stillbirth, loss of a baby at delivery, is a painful challenge. The suffering associated with the loss of a child, even before birth, can be overwhelming. Especially acute for women that have conceived utilizing assisted reproduction, the loss of a pregnancy fought through reproductive technology can overwhelm a couple. Stillbirth is a rare risk of pregnancy; the challenge facing us as reproductive medicine experts and obstetricians is how to reduce that risk.
The technologies of in vitro fertilization (IVF) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) have enabled pregnancy for thousands of families with sperm, egg, and uterine problems. With IVF, egg quality can be optimized using fertility drugs to produce more eggs. Blocked fallopian tubes can be bypassed. Weak sperm can achieve pregnancy by ICSI, where, using a microscopic needle, the sperm cell can be introduced into the egg.
No-one should expect these techniques to be foolproof. While mechanical problems can be improved, other weaknesses in the reproductive system cannot. Small deviations in the genetic code of the sperm or egg, missing chromosomes, aging, uterine defects, etc cannot be fixed by treating the sperm cell or embryo.
Thus the problem – these pregnancies established by high technology, are at higher risk.
A recent study from Denmark looked at stillbirth in children born after IVF/ICSI and found that the risk was higher in children born after IVF/ICSI than natural pregnancy. Out of 16,525 births to fertile women the chance of stillbirth was 0.37%, that is, 3.7 out of 1000 births. Out of 742 babies born to women after IVF/ICSI there were 12 stillbirths, 1.62%, that is 16.2 out of 1000 births.
But more importantly to our patients, the liveborn baby rate after a successful IVF/ICSI treatment and pregnancy is 98.4%. The liveborn baby rate after a successful natural conception and pregnancy is 99.6%. Almost all of the successful pregnancies after IVF/ICSI are liveborn.
Reproductive technologies, like IVF and ICSI, are enabling pregnancy and family building where it was not possible before. All of our patients must be informed of and recognize the risks associated with fertility treatment. These risks should not, however, dissuade anyone from considering these therapies. On the contrary, the overwhelming likelihood is that, once a pregnancy is established, it will progress successfully to delivery and a healthy child.
We need to recognize these risks to provide help understand and take measures to reduce the risks to all children. We will continue to watch these studies carefully in our ongoing effort to assure our patients of excellent pregnancy rates, at low risk.

Footnote:
- K. Wisborg, H.J. Ingerslev, and T.B. Henriksen IVF and stillbirth: a prospective follow-up study Hum. Reprod. Advance Access published on February 23, 2010.
Tags: ICSI, IVF - In Vitro Fertilization, Risks of Advanced Reproductive Technologies













